What Were They Thinking?

Our public radio station, WAMC, has a pretty serious commitment to local news. They do a good job covering serious topics — so when I heard the story, College Community Shaken by Student Death it really got my attention. The piece was about the tragic passing of UAlbany student Trevor Duffy. You can read or listen to the story here. A couple of thoughts:

I can excuse that the headline has nothing to do with what’s in the story — and that the reporter, Dave Lucas, didn’t bother talking to a single student or UAlbany staff member.

It’s also understandable that he would rely so heavily on information from other media, referencing stories from WNYT, Time Warner and “some reports” as his source of quotes and points of fact.

And the story’s tortured attempt to paint this as a town and gown issue, summoning up the Kegs ‘n’ Eggs riot of 2011? I don’t agree with the premise, but it’s a harmless idea.

But what’s truly atrocious — in fact, one of the most revolting things I’ve seen recently — is how the reporter cites several items from “an account on Twitter that appears to be Duffy’s.” He uses these tweets, presented without any legitimate context, to try making a point about the student’s state of mind. That’s just downright sleazy.

Look, I understand that sometimes you need to throw something together. Every story isn’t going to be a finely cut gem — but where are the editors who are supposed to keep crap like that off the air? That’s a mystery.

2 thoughts on “What Were They Thinking?

  1. Well, I took the time to listen to the story.

    Yes it’s flimsy, but that doesn’t really surprise me. Like you, I was taken aback by the tweets. That’s the sort of sensationalistic garbage I’d expect from a local TV station, not on public radio. “Sleazy” is an accurate description.

    WAMC’s local news coverage is admirable, but not without issues. As you pointed some of the reporting is weak, and much of the news is so local it has little interest to the listeners in their broad coverage area.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *